ISO MORE PERFECT DOLPHINS LOSSES

There is no such thing as a good loss, but the Miami Dolphins 19-9 loss to the Detroit Lions was damn-near perfect.

With eight games in the books and a lonely “1” in the win column, opining perfection is not easy to come by.

On the other hand, the youngest team in the National Football League by a landslide just played head-up with the league’s best offense at the season’s midpoint.

And better yet, they lost.

JUDGMENT-FREE ZONE

Look – rooting for your favorite team to lose is not only counter-intuitive, it leaves one exposed to being judged by the fellow fan.

But when it comes to this year’s team, a few things can be established that would suggest that hoping they lose – while still battling for four quarters every week – is actually logical. Here are three reasons:

First, quarterback Malik Willis was just placed on injured reserve for his ailing groin. It would not be unfair to suggest his play has been erratic, at best. There will be four games left when he returns and regardless of how he plays, it’s hard to imagine it will feel like “we’ve found the answer.”

The second item for consideration is how things are shaking out this year when it comes to the draft.

What was once considered a generational draft for quarterbacks is now down to basically two main candidates for the Top 5 of the draft – Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker and Notre Dame’s C.J. Carr. Two talented players with different skill sets and only one – Mestemaker – with traits that tantalize. He likely won’t make the third pick of the draft, no matter what is being currently projected.

Finally, the most salient of all points: despite its record, head coach Jeff Hafley has this team playing with enough juice that it’s noticeable. They’ve won one game but nobody is making Dolphins jokes. And with roster not only dotted with young unproven players, it’s covered with them.

Last year it was the Lions poking fun of the Dolphins for being soft. This year, their hard-nosed head coach Dan Campbell took notice.

“Coach Hafley is doing a hell of a job,” Campbel said post game. “That team plays hard. The tape said so. We knew it would be that way.”

Because of all this, it’s hard to imagine that MIami will be in a position to pick this high again. Or at least not without giving up extra capital.

WHAT TO DO WITH WILLIS

The short answer to the above header is “nothing.”

Willis will hopefully heal completely then step right back into the starting role. Maybe McCord will move the team better in his absence, but unless there is just simply no denying McCord after four games, the ball should go back to Willis. He signed with Miami when he didn’t have to and he has traits that deserve a longer look and chance at development.

And even if he comes back and the play is unchanged, Willis should enter next training camp as the team’s starter.

Let’s dream and say Miami has a pick high enough to select Mestemaker, and they do. Again, like McCord, if he just can’t be denied in training camp, so be it. But Willis getting the chance to play well only helps the organization.

If he plays well enough to help them win in the season’s second half, this whole conversation is likely forgotten. But save that scenario, his playing better benefits the Dolphins not only at face value and in presenting the team with its potential future, but also adding to his value should the time come to turn the reins over to a youngster.

Regardless, there is no need to live in shame Dolphins fans. Hoping the team has a shot at a high pick next year isn’t sports nihilism – it’s the realization that the new people in charge have things headed in the right direction and this may be the last realistic chance there is at drafting a franchise quarterback.



GET ACR IN YOUR INBOX FIRST

Greg Creese